Jump to content
Accelerated Evolution

Bush grants himself the option of dictatorial powers


Recommended Posts

  • Replies 67
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

If people could actually agree and work together they could.

Not make it perfect or anything, but fix some problems. No one agrees on anything anymore though.

That wouldn't do much either. You can't provoke change in the government if the voice of the people falls on deaf ears. Clearly our current administration is devoted to doing the exact opposite of what the majority of the American people want.

Link to comment

So, anyone remember the Roman Republic? Because that's exactly what happened there. The consul gave himself emergency powers, then never stopped having an emergency, etc.

After a few generations they just called them Emperors.

Except that was that built into the Roman system as a way for the senate not to get into the way during Total War.

We also have a similar protection; congress is given the power to declare war but once War is declared then the President is in complete charge of the military.

Also, I *believe* the senate needed to accept the Dictator *looks it up*

Yup. from Wikipedia:

When a dictator was considered necessary, the Senate passed a senatus consultum that one of the consuls should nominate a dictator; and without a previous decree of the senate, the consuls had not the power of naming a dictator. The nomination of the dictator by the consul was necessary in all cases. It was always made by the consul, probably without any witnesses, between midnight and morning.

Also, the system worked until Ceaser abused it. Dictators served only 6 month terms and most give away their power after the crisis was over.

Link to comment

That wouldn't do much either. You can't provoke change in the government if the voice of the people falls on deaf ears. Clearly our current administration is devoted to doing the exact opposite of what the majority of the American people want.

Apparently not when they've been voted in.

No, if everyone truly hated the administration enough they would be overthrown.

Link to comment

Except that was that built into the Roman system as a way for the senate not to get into the way during Total War.

We also have a similar protection; congress is given the power to declare war but once War is declared then the President is in complete charge of the military.

Also, I *believe* the senate needed to accept the Dictator *looks it up*

Yup. from Wikipedia:

When a dictator was considered necessary, the Senate passed a senatus consultum that one of the consuls should nominate a dictator; and without a previous decree of the senate, the consuls had not the power of naming a dictator. The nomination of the dictator by the consul was necessary in all cases. It was always made by the consul, probably without any witnesses, between midnight and morning.

Also, the system worked until Ceaser abused it. Dictators served only 6 month terms and most give away their power after the crisis was over.

Perhaps I didn't understand it as well as I thought I did. Still, it's similar. Although their system was certainly better... Imagine that, 2000 years of progress, and for what?

Link to comment

Please sign in to comment

You will be able to leave a comment after signing in



Sign In Now

×
×
  • Create New...